Mr McCLELLAND (Barton) (10.30 a.m.) —Yes, Mr Speaker. The Prime Minister's office has breached security for blatantly political purposes.
Dr STONE (Murray—Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for the Environment and Heritage) (10.30 a.m.)—I move:
That the member be not further heard.
Question agreed to.
Original question put:
That the motion (Mr Fitzgibbon's) be agreed to.
The House divided. [10.32 a.m.](The Speaker—Mr Neil Andrew)
| Ayes............ | 55 |
| Noes............ | 72 |
| Majority......... | 17 |
| Adams, D.G.H. | Albanese, A.N. |
| Beazley, K.C. | Bevis, A.R. |
| Byrne, A.M. | Corcoran, A.K. |
| Cox, D.A. | Crean, S.F. |
| Crosio, J.A. | Danby, M. * |
| Edwards, G.J. | Ellis, A.L. |
| Evans, M.J. | Ferguson, M.J. |
| Fitzgibbon, J.A. | Gibbons, S.W. |
| Gillard, J.E. | Grierson, S.J. |
| Griffin, A.P. | Hall, J.G. |
| Hatton, M.J. | Hoare, K.J. |
| Irwin, J. | Jackson, S.M. |
| Jenkins, H.A. | Kerr, D.J.C. |
| King, C.F. | Livermore, K.F. |
| Macklin, J.L. | McClelland, R.B. |
| McFarlane, J.S. | McLeay, L.B. |
| McMullan, R.F. | Melham, D. |
| Mossfield, F.W. | Murphy, J. P. |
| O'Byrne, M.A. | O'Connor, B.P. |
| O'Connor, G.M. | Organ, M. |
| Plibersek, T. | Price, L.R.S. |
| Quick, H.V. * | Ripoll, B.F. * |
| Sawford, R.W. | Sciacca, C.A. |
| Sercombe, R.C.G. | Sidebottom, P.S. |
| Smith, S.F. | Tanner, L. |
| Thomson, K.J. | Vamvakinou, M. * |
| Wilkie, K. | Windsor, A.H.C. |
| Zahra, C.J. |
| Abbott, A.J. | Andrews, K.J. |
| Anthony, L.J. | Bailey, F.E. |
| Baird, B.G. | Baldwin, R.C. |
| Barresi, P.A. | Bartlett, K.J. |
| Billson, B.F. | Bishop, B.K. |
| Bishop, J.I. | Brough, M.T. |
| Cadman, A.G. | Cameron, R.A. |
| Causley, I.R. | Charles, R.E. |
| Ciobo, S.M. | Cobb, J.K. |
| Costello, P.H. | Draper, P. |
| Dutton, P.C. | Elson, K.S. |
| Entsch, W.G. | Farmer, P.F. |
| Forrest, J.A. * | Gallus, C.A. |
| Gambaro, T. | Gash, J. * |
| Georgiou, P. | Haase, B.W. |
| Hardgrave, G.D. | Hartsuyker, L. |
| Hawker, D.P.M. | Hockey, J.B. |
| Hull, K.E. | Hunt, G.A. |
| Johnson, M.A. | Jull, D.F. |
| Kelly, D.M. | Kemp, D.A. |
| King, P.E. | Ley, S.P. |
| Lindsay, P.J. | Lloyd, J.E. |
| Macfarlane, I.E. | May, M.A. |
| McArthur, S. * | Moylan, J. E. |
| Nairn, G. R. | Nelson, B.J. |
| Neville, P.C. * | Panopoulos, S. |
| Prosser, G.D. | Pyne, C. |
| Randall, D.J. | Ruddock, P.M. |
| Scott, B.C. | Secker, P.D. |
| Slipper, P.N. | Somlyay, A.M. |
| Southcott, A.J. | Stone, S.N. |
| Thompson, C.P. | Ticehurst, K.V. |
| Tollner, D.W. | Truss, W.E. |
| Tuckey, C.W. | Vale, D.S. |
| Wakelin, B.H. | Washer, M.J. |
| Williams, D.R. | Worth, P.M. |
* denotes teller
Question negatived.